
From Father to Nothing · chapter nine
The Checklist
Previously: Good Endings
If we knew what to do to make a business work well, somebody would have written it down by now and we would all follow it. We do not know. The world changes, the market changes, and every change is a coin toss. What can be written down is how to hand a business on. That part repeats itself in the same way every time.
A will does not solve it. Nor does any other document. A handover has to be worked through like any other business. If you do not work through it in your lifetime, what you leave behind is an unprepared battlefield. Operational, financial and, above all, emotional. And your heirs will be dealing with it in the hardest period of their lives.
This chapter is a list. Nothing more. Most of the points you already know from the previous chapters; here they are in one place, so that you can tick them off. The first list is for founders. The second is for successors. And at the end there are a few questions for both, at one table.
For founders.
Assets first. That is the easier part.
Separate clean assets from operations. Real estate goes into a company of its own that only lets. Operations separately, each with its own risk.
If you have several companies, put a holding company above them. Profit goes one floor up and comes back down only when that makes sense.
End cross-guarantees. Assets unrelated to the operations do not guarantee their loans.
Close the loss-making parts. Count your own time too. What breaks even on paper is usually losing money in reality. Is your hope of future profit really justified?
Put the assets into a company or a trust, so that shares are inherited and divided. Keep the whole in working order.
Whoever does the work gets more. Roughly what you would pay an outsider. Agree on it while things are calm.
While things are calm, write down the rest as well: who works and what they get for it, how a partner can leave and for how much, when and how much is paid out to those who do not work, and how the votes are counted.
Then the family. That is harder.
Talk about the wealth out loud. How much you have, what you owe and what did not work out. The children will find out one day anyway, only without you.
Ask yourself what the money is for. Before you ask who gets it.
Judge the successor without sentiment. Entrepreneurs make up around ten per cent of the population. The best evidence is the child’s own profitable business, ideally outside your firm.
Do not bet on a child just because they are the nearest. It is a bet on a single number at roulette, and the stake is the relationship.
Distinguish ownership from management. Owning can be learned. Running a business cannot.
Give the children what matters around the age of thirty. Housing, education. At fifty or later, when they inherit, it will not improve their lives.
Write a will, ideally as a notarial deed. And know that it is a fraction of the solution, not the solution.
Bring in someone from outside who has been through a handover. It is windy at the top of the structure, and you are alone there.
Finally the handover. The hardest part is stepping back.
Build the exit before you need it. Management that is not a partner. A share that can be sold. Prepare for a sale even if you do not want to sell.
Hand over in parts.
Try it more than once. Handing over or selling a small part is the real experience. For you and for the successor alike.
Sell while there is something to sell. The price is not set by what you put in, but by whoever pays.
Decide who you are after you leave. The monarch who is carried out, the general who comes back, the ambassador on hand, or the governor who moves on.
Be a listening ear, not a second track. Speak well of the successor, whatever you may think. Whoever comes to you, send to them.
Have somewhere to go. Whoever does not know what he will do the next morning does not leave.
Speculate with the proceeds as little as possible. Investing is an entirely different game from business.
Let the next generation hand something over or sell something too. Let them learn. Not merely keep what is there.
For successors.
The first week. When it comes unprepared.
If you do not know, take advice from someone who has been through it.
Write down who owes what to whom. Across the companies, and towards the partners.
Home first. Let the family speak with one voice before you go to the partners. Pull in the same direction.
The first year. The battlefield.
Map it before you do anything on it. Who sides with whom, what was promised, what holds only by custom. You discover an unwritten rule only when you break it.
Stop the bleeding wherever money is being lost. Support what earns.
Count the votes. With half you can block anything; with two thirds you can push through substantial changes. And still want everyone’s consent. Whoever is outvoted does not cooperate.
Go into the negotiations with one sentence and repeat it to the end.
Listen. Even shouting and tears clear the air. Someone who has been heard gives way more readily.
Give respect in advance. Not agreement. Ask yourself how you would behave if it had been the other partner who died, and not your father.
Once the bleeding has stopped, clean up. First the loss-making operations, then the separation of assets, then pay for the work.
Do not compete with your predecessor. You cannot compete with a dead man, but he should not have voting rights either.
Later. Once it stops being a rescue.
Bring something of your own. If you have not done so yet, do it now. A business of your own, even a failed one, is the best school.
Choose your people. In time you should have a team as if you had been choosing it yourself all along. Where you are not playing for the same side, part.
Look after your relationship with your parents and siblings. It tends to be worth more than the business itself.
Build an exit for yourself too. The handover will come round again. One day you will be on the other side of the table.
Leave room for humility. The lesson will come either way.
For both, at one table.
These questions are not for ticking. They are for asking out loud. I have picked a few from the cards that belong to this book; the deck can be downloaded at fromfathertonothing.com. Do not look for the answers in the book, but in the people sitting across from you.
What is the money for?
Are you the center of a star-shaped structure in the company? If so, what happens when you disappear?
Do your children have the same entrepreneurial talent as you? Is it fair to expect them to run the business?
What of the firm should survive, even if the firm does not?
Which of us can say no, and to whom?
If everything were sold today, who would stop calling whom?
My father and I never asked them. Then there was no time. You still have it.